
Given the choice, I'm likin' Sarahs better. Just sayin...
Economics, politics, law and ranting - Got it covered? No more nice....no sugar, no spice. The world sucks and here is my take on how to fix it....
The County seeks to undercut the plaintiffs’ equal protection claim by asserting the plaintiffs are not similarly situated to heterosexuals.The County references this threshold test in this case and asserts the
plaintiffs are not similarly situated to opposite-sex couples so as to
necessitate further equal protection analysis because the plaintiffs cannot
“procreate naturally.”
Therefore, with respect to the subject and purposes of Iowa’s marriage
laws, we find that the plaintiffs are similarly situated compared to
heterosexual persons. Plaintiffs are in committed and loving relationships,
many raising families, just like heterosexual couples. Moreover, official
recognition of their status provides an institutional basis for defining their
fundamental relational rights and responsibilities, just as it does for
heterosexual couples. Society benefits, for example, from providing samesex
couples a stable framework within which to raise their children and the
power to make health care and end-of-life decisions for loved ones, just as it
does when that framework is provided for opposite-sex couples.
In short, for purposes of Iowa’s marriage laws, which are designed to
bring a sense of order to the legal relationships of committed couples and
their families in myriad ways, plaintiffs are similarly situated in every
important respect, but for their sexual orientation. As indicated above, this
distinction cannot defeat the application of equal protection analysis
The County initially points out that section 595.2 does not explicitly
refer to “sexual orientation” and does not inquire into whether either
member of a proposed civil marriage is sexually attracted to the other.
Consequently, it seizes on these observations to support its claim that the
statute does not establish a classification on the basis of sexual orientation
because the same-sex civil marriage ban does not grant or withhold the
benefits flowing from the statute based on sexual preference. Instead, the
County argues, section 595.2 only incidentally impacts disparately upon gay
and lesbian people.
The County’s position reveals the importance of accurately and
precisely defining the classification in analyzing all equal protection
challenges. The manner in which a classification is defined impacts the
utility of an equal protection analysis as a means of revealing discrimination.
Therefore, it is critical that a court reviewing the statute identify the true
nature of the classification.
It is true the marriage statute does not expressly prohibit gay and
lesbian persons from marrying; it does, however, require that if they marry,
it must be to someone of the opposite sex. Viewed in the complete context of
marriage, including intimacy, civil marriage with a person of the opposite sex
is as unappealing to a gay or lesbian person as civil marriage with a person
of the same sex is to a heterosexual. Thus, the right of a gay or lesbian
person under the marriage statute to enter into a civil marriage only with a
person of the opposite sex is no right at all. Under such a law, gay or
lesbian individuals cannot simultaneously fulfill their deeply felt need for a
committed personal relationship, as influenced by their sexual orientation,
and gain the civil status and attendant benefits granted by the statute.
Instead, a gay or lesbian person can only gain the same rights under the
statute as a heterosexual person by negating the very trait that defines gay and lesbian people as a class—their sexual orientation. In re Marriage Cases, 183 P.3d at 441. The benefit denied by the marriage statute—the status of civil marriage for same-sex couples—is so “closely correlated with being homosexual” as to make it apparent the law is targeted at gay and lesbian people as a class. See Lawrence, 539 U.S. at 583, 123 S. Ct. at 2486, 156 L. Ed. 2d at 529 (O’Connor, J., concurring) (reviewing criminalization of homosexual sodomy and concluding that “[w]hile it is true that the law applies only to conduct, the conduct targeted by this law is conduct that is closely correlated with being homosexual. Under such
circumstances, [the] sodomy law is targeted at more than conduct. It is instead directed toward gay persons as a class.”). The Court’s decision in Romer v. Evans, 517 U.S. 620, 116 S. Ct. 1620, 134 L. Ed. 2d 855 (1996), supports this conclusion. Romer can be read to imply that sexual orientation is a trait that defines an individual and is not merely a means to associate a group with a type of behavior. See Romer, 517 U.S. at 632, 116 S. Ct. at 1627, 134 L. Ed. 2d at 865–66 (holding an amendment to a state constitution pertaining to “homosexual . . . orientation” expresses “animus toward the class that it affects”).
By purposefully placing civil marriage outside the realistic reach of gay and lesbian individuals, the ban on same-sex civil marriages differentiates implicitly on the basis of sexual orientation. See Kerrigan, 957 A.2d at 431 n.24; Conaway v. Deane, 932 A.2d 571, 605 (Md. 2007). Thus, we proceed to analyze the constitutionality of the statute based on sexual orientation discrimination.
The County has proffered a number of objectives supporting the marriage statute. These objectives include support for the “traditional” institution of marriage, the optimal procreation and rearing of children, and financial considerations.
The first step in scrutinizing a statutory classification can be to determine whether the objectives purportedly advanced by the classification are important. “The burden of justification is demanding and it rests entirely on the State.”
In America, there is a failure to appreciate Europe's leading role in the world.
With all the bruhaha going on about Rush Limbaugh's statement hoping for the failure of President Obama's policy I wanted to make a comment to my Congressional delegation:Given the policies and plans proposed and supported by President Obama, I hope they fail as they will neither help our Country's current economic situation, nor benefit our Country in the long term. If you support his policies, then I hope you fail also.
| Based on Wisconsin CCAP Charlie has: -More than twice the Courtroom & Trial experience of his two opponents combined -More Diverse Experience: | |||
| Charlie | Stephen | Julie | |
| Divorce & Family Cases(inc. Adoption, Paternity, Custody & Support, GP Visitation) | 752 | 0 | 0 |
| Civil Litigation/Personal Injury | 116 | 176 | 28 |
| Criminal Felony cases | 64 | 19* *(Inc. 5 as ADA) | 0 |
| Criminal Misd/Traffic/OWI (1st Offense OWI are not on CCAP) | 474 | 1,026* *(inc. 999 as ADA) | 0 |
| Estate Probates | 27 | 0 | 0 |
| Juvenile/CHIPS (Not on CCAP) | 101 | ? | ? |
| Bankruptcy (Federal Court) | 704 | 0 | 0 |
| Real Estate Matters | 65 | 0 | 0 |
| Wills & POAs | 343 | 0 | 0 |
| Business Formations | 27 | 0 | 0 |
| Current Tax Clients | 165 | 0 | 0 |
| Other Areas of Law | 466 | ? | ? |
| Charlie has handled Jury Trials in Criminal Felonies & Misdemeanors,Personal Injury, Contract Litigation, CHIPS and TPRs. Almost anything that might come before a Circuit Judge, Charlie has hands on experience in. As a CPA, he understands the financial and tax aspects of cases. Charlie has practiced in: Adams, Columbia, Dane, Dodge, FonDuLac, Iowa, Jefferson, Juneau, Marathon, Marquette, Milwaukee, Rock, Sauk, Sheboygan , Walworth and Washington Counties, Wisconsin Federal Courts and the U.S. Tax Court. | |||
| 1. | Citigroup (New York, N.Y.) | $2,199,848 |
| 2. | Bank of America Corp. (Charlotte, N.C.) | 1,743,478 |
| 3. | J. P. Morgan Chase & Company (Columbus, Ohio) | 1,642,862 |
| 4. | Wachovia Corp. (Charlotte, N.C.) | 808,575 |
| 5. | Taunus Corp. (New York, N.Y.) | 750,323 |
| 6. | Wells Fargo & Company (San Fransisco, Calif.) | 595,221 |
| 7. | HSBC North America Inc. (Prospect Heights, Ill.) | 493,010 |
| 8. | U.S. Bancorp (Minneapolis, Minn.) | 241,781 |
| 9. | Bank of the New York Mellon Corp. (New York, N.Y.) | 205,151 |
| 10. | Suntrust, Inc. (Atlanta, Ga.) | 178,986 |
| 11. | Citizens Financial Group, Inc. (Providence, R.I.) | 161,759 |
| 12. | National City Bank (Cleveland, Ohio) | 155,046 |
| 13. | State Street Corp. (Boston, MA) | 154,478 |
| 14. | Capital One Financial Corp. (McLean, Va.) | 150,608 |
| 15. | Regions Financial Corp. (Birmingham, Ala.) | 144,251 |
| 16. | PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. (Pittsburg, Pa.) | 140,026 |
| 17. | BB&T Corp. (Winston-Salem, N.C.) | $136,417 |
| 18. | TD Bank North, INC. (Portland, Maine) | 118,171 |
| 19. | Fifth Third Bankcorp (Cincinatti, Ohio) | 111,396 |
| 20. | Keycorp (Cleveland, Ohio) | 101,596 |
The only part of the conduct of any one, for which he is amenable to society, is that which concerns others. In the part which merely concerns himself, his independence is, of right, absolute. Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign.
Much of Obama's overall appeal stems from his image as practically a post-racial politician. Not only does he have a mixed-race background, with a white mother from Kansas and a black father from Kenya, but his rhetoric, most notably his 2004 Democratic National Convention speech, emphasizes the importance of Americans moving beyond political, religious and racial differences. He rarely makes explicit appeals based on his race the way Jackson did. " A lot of black people aren't ready to get beyond race, because race puts them in the situation they're in," said Ron Walters, a professor at the University of Maryland who worked on Jesse Jackson's Presidential runs. "But many whites want to get beyond the past, they want to support a black person who doesn't raise the past and in fact gives them absolution from the past."
From Time, Jan 23, 2007
In 2004, George W. Bush attracted 11 percent of the black vote, up from the 9 percent he garnered in 2000. In 1996, Bob Dole, running against the nation's so-called "first black president," Bill Clinton, received 12 percent. And now with Obama in the picture, more conservative blacks may feel compelled to join the heftier group of black voters who support the Democrat.
"They're practical if nothing else, and they want to see a black president," Ronald Walters, a professor of government and politics at the University of Maryland, says of black Republican voters. "The historical factor is going to overrun some of the other considerations." In a recent Washington Post-ABC News poll, 7 percent of the surveyed African-American adults supported McCain, while 90 percent supported Obama.
From US News, Jun 27, 2008
I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.